In terms of journalism nothing seems to gain readers attention more than death. From everyday people to those in the public eye, readers are instantly transfixed by these people’s stories. Obituaries are an essential part of any newspaper and with its inclusion in newspapers comes the responsibility to accurately tell their life’s story. However there is also the seeming responsibility to record these facts in a style devoid of malice or contempt. That can be difficult when the subject of an obituary is a polarizing person whom many hold high disdain for.
This happens to be the case for Robert McNamara, after his death on July 6, 2009. McNamara was viewed by many as the behind the scenes man orchestrating the Vietnam War. To few he was viewed as a political advisor, while many others viewed him simply as a war criminal. The obituary that was written for him by Joseph L. Galloway of McClatchley Newspapers was one which made no attempt at trying to hide the authors disdain for McNamara. For example the opening line of the obituary read
“Well, the aptly named Robert Strange McNamara has finally
shuffled off to join LBJ and Dick Nixon in the 7th level of Hell.”
Throughout the obituary Galloway makes reference to personal experiences he had with McNamara. At one point even discussing an exchange he had with a friend about which one of them hated McNamara more. The obituary ends as some do with an anecdote. However this anecdote retold the story of how McNamara was almost thrown off of a ferry leaving Martha’s Vineyard by an enraged fellow passenger.
This would leave many out there wondering whether or not this was the most appropriate way to remember someone’s life, even if they were known for notorious reasons. The argument can be made that despite a widespread dislike, even hatred, for a person at least one individual will be affected by their passing. This can argued several ways. First no matter what an obituary is no place to mention a person’s mistakes, character flaws, or past misgivings. Or secondly if someone is made famous or notorious for their deeds their reputation was made from these actions making their notoriety forever the same in the public record. The only right answer is one which can be ascertained by the journalist themselves. There needs to be a happy medium where it is understood that most mistakes in life will be forgotten and your life will be celebrated upon your passing. While if your notoriety was based solely on your nefarious reputation, than those facts will undoubtedly need to be included in any retelling of your life’s story.
Galloway, J. L. (2009, July 6). Commentary: Galloway on McNamara: Reading an obit with great pleasure. McClatchly Newspapers. Retrieved January 15, 2010, from http://www.mcclatchydc.com/homepage/story/71328.html
McBride, L. H. (2009, July 7). McNamara, Vietnam, the Baby Boom and the ethics of unkind obits. Retrieved January 15, 2010, from http://www.examiner.com/x-2134-DC-Ethical-Issues-Examiner~y2009m7d7-McNamara-Vietnam-the-Baby-Boom-and-the-ethics-of-unkind-obits